Enjoy a Chinese banquet but boycott the evil of shark fin soup – photo essay

betty ming liu Food, Travel 11 Comments

A typical Chinese banquet can be an insanely delicious 10-course orgy. While I’ve attended a few fab vegetarian versions of this feast, most events are heavy on meat and seafood. Unfortunately, these menus also feature one item that symbolizes the brutality of Chinese food culture: shark fin soup.

Chinese banquets go on 24/7 to celebrate just about any occasion. Starting Thursday (Feb. 3), there will be endless worldwide feasting to the arrival of Lunar New Year. If you’re invited to a Year of the Rabbit event, here’s a chance to build awareness by tactfully asking the host what’s up for the soup course. And if you’re hosting a dinner, there’s still time to take shark fin off the menu.

This delicacy gets to the banquet table as follows: fishermen catch a shark, slice off its fins — and toss the helpless, live, bleeding creature overboard. It can’t swim anymore and suffocates as it sinks into the ocean.

Meanwhile, its fins are dried and sold at premium prices in Asian markets. Restaurants reconstitute the fins in water, shred them and simmer the strands into a tasty, gelatinous broth. Just before serving, the soup is finished with a splash of dark, pungent vinegar. Some progressive restaurants are serving a shark fin alternative made from a gelatin base. But not enough establishments are in the conservation mode — yet.

To learn more about the issue as well as about the role of sharks in the eco-system, check out the website for Stop Shark Finning. This advocacy group has posted a bunch of very watchable videos about the whole topic — including wrenching footage on this horrible practice.

The timeline to protect sharks from finning began in 2007 at the United Nations. A few weeks ago, Pres. Obama signed into law new regulations to close the immoral and inhumane practice of shark finning. And starting this summer, Hawaii will become the first state to ban the sale of shark fin soup.

You can also hand out Chinese-English bilingual fliers to restaurant owners and others, letting them know how you feel about the issue. The Humane Society has created fliers for us to download for free at its website.

I don’t want this post to be a total downer. So I’ll segue now into photos from a relative’s recent Chinatown wedding banquet. It was a wonderful event — and also the first one my daughter has attended since she was a baby. The bride was Latina (finally, adding more diversity to the family tree!) and she was gorgeous.

And yes, there was shark fin soup. But yes, it was also a chance to discuss the issue and build some awareness for the future.

As an agricultural-based society, a proud Chinese host serves tons of meat & seafood in a show of prosperity. You'd never serve rice during the meal & stuff your guests with cheap carb filler. So rice and noodles come out at the end, just before dessert.

Suckling pig combo platter with jellyfish and assorted meat cold cuts.

Conch & scallop with sugar snap peas in edible taro root "nest"

Shrimp & walnut with broccoli stir-fry

Shark fin soup. For the record, the newlyweds had no idea of the controversy until I explained shark finning to them -- after the banquet.

Sliced abalone & fish fillet with vegetables

Crispy "fried chicken" with shrimp chips. Notice that the chicken is bloody at the bone. Not a mistake. This is how this dish is served. The skin is super crispy.

Lobster with ginger & scallion sauce

A pair of steamed fish. A couple. Awww. The menu says "live" fish but should read "fresh" fish. Chinglish!

Fried rice & double-fried e-fu noodles always end a banquet.

Dessert was an East-West sampler.

The happy couple had a pretty, Western-style wedding cake. There were also Chinese pastries — an acquired taste because they’re not sugary or buttery.

I love this sweet aduki bean soup. It’s brimming with gingko nuts, tiny tapioca pearls and boiled peanuts.

To see shots of a really lovely Chinese wedding banquet from start to finish, I have a new photo album on my facebook page. Some of the food was more than we could handle. My daughter’s a vegetarian and because of that, I don’t each much meat anymore. So I’d like to add this….for an excellent vegetarian banquet or meal of any sort, check out Buddha Bodai. There are two locations, one in Manhattan’s Chinatown or Flushing, Queens.


Comments 11

  1. Post

    i hope this thing reads okay. gotta run now to class. will proof read it more carefully later. if you spot any typos, please let me know and i’ll tidy up. thanks. :-)

  2. Pingback: Tweets that mention Enjoy a Chinese banquet but boycott the evil of shark fin soup – photo essay -- Topsy.com

  3. Betty– Absolutely fascinating. I had no idea about shark fin soup. Is there some reason they simply don’t harvest the entire shark, because people do eat shark. All the food in your photos looks delicious — thanks for sharing (and educating).

  4. Lovely photos. Looks like a fun party.

    That sucks about the sharks. I’m wondering the same thing as Susan–if they’re going to de-fin the sharks, why not eat them as well? Why throw them overboard? What a waste.

    Thanks for bringing awareness about this practice.

  5. Post

    I had no idea about shark fin until two summers ago — when a student wrote about it in my NYU “Food Writing” class. Revolting, isn’t it?

    In answer to your question, there’s a theory in Chinese medicine known as The Law of Signature. Since the shark’s fins are powerful muscular devices, I’m sure the original thinking is that if you eat the fin, you’ll be stronger too. A twisted view on Chinese medicine is also directly responsible for the decimation of the tiger population. Tiger parts are harvested to increase virility. http://www.tigersincrisis.com/siberian_tiger.htm

    This is sick, sick, sick — and the dark side of a form of Chinese medicine that responsible practitioners abhor. The crowd I hang with takes an herbal approach to health. https://bettymingliu.com/2011/01/chinese-medicine-master-jeffrey-yuens-essential-health-beauty-diet-regimen/

  6. Post

    oh, and the thing about shark meat — it just doesn’t have the same taste, texture or energetic function. when i was in hawaii, i actually tried shark steak. it’s tasty but not my thing! but it definitely comes across as a fish-eating experience. the fin is a stringy, chewy experience that isn’t comparable to anything else that i can think of.

  7. I didn’t know about the fins, either. (I have enjoyed shark steak before, though). This is really tough to swallow, no pun intended. I’m glad you shared this when you did, because I’m attending a Chinese wedding banquet at the end of February. I’m pretty sure that your post will be in my head if I see shark fin soup.

  8. Post
  9. Betty, thanks for sharing and bringing awareness to all our us. I had absolutely no idea this is such a brutal act to satisfy one’s palate. As much as I love shark’s fin soup, I now will take it off my menu.

  10. Pingback: Cooking with Kian: The only Chinese cookbook you’ll ever need | betty ming liu

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *